Motorcycle Forums banner

Aussie GP Results

16194 Views 91 Replies 36 Participants Last post by  PoppySTS
I think we had this same discussion last year at the same time.



Obviously, Rossi is the best of his generation, by far. When he is racing, it is usually for second place for the rest of the field.

1 - 3 of 92 Posts
I think that "harder to control" has different meanings in different contexts.



I would submit that today's bikes can accept much finer control inputs, and will respond immediately and predictably. However, that means that clumsy or excessive control input will also yield catastrophic results much more quickly.



The implication is that today's bikes are actually much easier to ride fast when you are paying attention to what you are doing - but will similarly get you in trouble much more quickly. You can prove it to yourself by riding a bike from 4 or 5 years ago, and riding the latest and greatest from today. The differences are, surprisingly, pretty dramatic.



cdg
See less See more
Oh I'm with you 100%. That's actually what I was (poorly) trying to say. I was going back to the insurance comment, which stated that the supersport bikes of today on the street are hard to control. That isn't precisely true. What's true is that they are very finely tuned, and respond instantly. To bad control inputs, to the street rider, this is bad.



For good / experienced riders, however, this is good. In other words, what I stated rather poorly, was the observation that it's not the bikes that are the problem (again, tying back to the nonsense from the Manitoba report) - it's almost always rider error.



A skilled racer would liekly not be caught out by today's bikes - but would likely begin denigrating today's riders, because the bikes are so easy to ride compared to the older ones, I would imagine. Note that I haven't ridden a late-80s Honda MotoGP bike, nor any of the current crop, so I'm probably talking out of my ass.



cdg
See less See more
It's very difficult to compare riders among generations, and even what the definition of greatest might be. Fastest race lap, race wins, qualifying - all measure slightly different things, and each is impacted by equipment and rider slightly differently.



I'd leave it with the observation that Rossi is a great champion - a genius - just like Doohan and others before. It's hard to say that he's better or worse because they'll never race on their best-matched equipment over a long enough horizon to pass judgment.



cdg
1 - 3 of 92 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top