Re: HUH?! BMW vs. Honda Reader Feedback
I've had three "oil heads"(and several "air heads" and two K bikes and a slew of Hondas and Yamahas), including an R1100GS. I've never had a transmission problem and have head of very few since the early problems. I do agree about the surging, BMW has screwed up big time on that. It is not that it is a major problem, it is that BMW should have fixed it quickly and they have taken much to long. As long as we are comparing Hondas and BMWs have you ridden a VFR800? They don't surge, exactly, but it is very hard to ride them smoothly at low speeds. I have read the other new, injected Honda have similar problems.
OTOH, you clearly know nothing about the PD bikes, they share about as many parts with the street bike and a NASCAR racer does with the street version. They are dirt bikes with a (reduced displacement to meet the rules) R1100 motor stuck in them, not modified street bikes.
The telelever bikes work better then most bikes with the stock (low grade) shock. If the front end of the GS is so bad why is the bike rated by just about every magazine as one of the best handling bikes in the world? For the $900 you spent you upgraded to a front end equal to a $3000+ set of Ohlins. BTW, you could have gotten 99% as good a front end by buying a $500 Fox shock.
You also have clearly never ridden any distance on an LT, saying the electric windshield is no different than remote lock proves that. You sound like the people who don't need electric clothing, they have never user it either.
I would never say BMWs are perfect, far from it. But it sounds to me like you bought the wrong bike for your tastes and needs and you are blaming BMW for your mistake. FWIW, I made the same mistake. I loved my R100GS and bought the R1100GS because I thought it was just an improved version of the R100. The R1100GS is, IMO, a bike for posers. It is useless in the dirt (I got my R100GS into and out of amazing places) and is in just about every measurable way inferior to the R1100R. It is JMHO but now that a Roadster that isn't butt ugly has come out I think R1100/ 1150GS sales will plummet. The Roadster was always a better bike but the thing was so ugly no one would buy them.