I had an Eclipse vest that was great, the only problem with it was that the collar was made of corduroy and that was very abrasive on your neck, so I sold it and got a Widder, that was a great vest also, but after reading about how great the Aerostich vest was, I sold that one too and purchased the Stich, well I am very dissapointed with it, it does not get as warm as the other two, when I got in touch with Aerostich and explained the problem, I was told that their product is designed that way and that was the end of that! I could not return it because I had had it for too long, I guess I should have tryed it right away.
Get the Widder and you will be very warm and happy.